Alabama DOC pays injured inmate $90,000

MONTGOMERY, ALABAMA, February 19, 2004 – The Alabama Department of Corrections (DOC) has paid $90,000.00 to an Alabama inmate who was injured when a piece of glass struck his eye while he was working at a recycling facility at the Elmore Correctional Facility in Elmore, AL. Brian Dodd, a Gulf War veteran and skilled welder serving a short sentence for a drug-related offense, had previously requested protective eye goggles before working in the facility. Several days after his request was denied, his eye was severely injured by a piece of flying glass.

Mr. Dodd, represented by the Southern Center for Human Rights in Atlanta, filed a federal lawsuit in Montgomery in May 2003 against the correctional officer who had denied him the goggles, Howard Robinson. In November, U.S. District Judge Mark E. Fuller rejected an attempt by the DOC to have Mr. Dodd’s lawsuit against him thrown out of court, and the judge ordered the case set for trial in April.

Attorneys for both sides reached an agreement this month which calls for the DOC to pay Mr. Dodd $90,000 for the resolution of his claims. The DOC has also agreed to pay for the evaluation and treatment of Mr. Dodd’s eye, which remains injured almost two years after the March 2002 accident at the recycling facility. "We believe this is a very fair settlement," said Mr. Dodd’s attorney, Ty Alper. "Mr. Dodd’s primary concern is getting his eye treated."

Mr. Alper and attorney Marion Chartoff, also with the Southern Center for Human Rights, filed a federal class action lawsuit against the Elmore facility several years ago. At the time, inmates working at the recycling facility were working without protective gear and were often stuck with used hypodermic needles and splashed with medical waste. As a result of that lawsuit, a settlement agreement was reached which required officers to provide protective gear to inmates working in the recycling facility.

"The officers at Elmore need to understand that there are serious consequences - for the inmates and for themselves - when they do not provide the protective gear that they are supposed to provide," said Mr. Alper. "Mr. Dodd’s injury was entirely preventable, if he had just been given a pair of eye goggles. We don’t expect this kind of thing to happen again."

According to Mr. Alper, Mr. Dodd is due to be released from prison before the end of the year.

For a copy of the Settlement Agreement, click here

For a copy of Judge Fuller's order denying the DOC's motion for summary judgment, click here

For a copy of the Complaint, click here

Click here for press accounts of the Elmore case

Return to Center's Efforts to Protect Human Rights